
Agency Insurance
Agency Insurance provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Wisconsin. Whether it's home, auto, life, or commercial insurance, they offer personalized service to ensure you have the right coverage.
Photos of Agency Insurance


Services Agency Insurance offers
Explore the range of insurance services provided by Agency Insurance:
- Home and Property Insurance
- Auto and Recreation Insurance
- Life Insurance
- Commercial Insurance
- Business Insurance
- Leisure Vehicle Insurance
- Bundle Packages
- Custom Policy Consultation
Agency Insurance business numbers & email addresses
Not available.
Location & directions
Visit Agency Insurance at 114 S Main St, Lake Mills, WI 53551. Conveniently located in Southern Wisconsin, we serve local and regional policyholders.
114 S Main St, Lake Mills, WI 53551, United States
Service hours
| Wednesday | 9 AM–5:30 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–5:30 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–5:30 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 9 AM–5:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 9 AM–5:30 PM |
Agency Insurance overview
Agency Insurance is a dedicated insurance firm located in Lake Mills, Wisconsin. With a mission to serve the local community, we provide personalized insurance solutions ranging from auto and home to business coverage. Our experienced team, led by Janine M. Fixmer, strives to offer expert guidance and tailored policies, ensuring our clients are well-protected no matter what life brings. We are a proud representative of ERIE Insurance.
Send letters & parcels
To send letters or parcels to Agency Insurance, direct them to our office located at 114 S Main St, Lake Mills, WI 53551. We welcome any queries, documents, or communication that can be delivered in person or via postal service. Please ensure your correspondence is clearly addressed to ensure it reaches the correct department promptly. Our dedicated staff will handle your mail efficiently.
Send a resume or CV
If you are interested in joining the Agency Insurance team, we encourage you to submit your resume or CV by postal mail to our office address at 114 S Main St, Lake Mills, WI 53551. Make sure your application includes all relevant experience and contact information for a prompt review. We look forward to considering your application.
Business highlights
- Rated 4.9 by customers for superior service
- Over 18 years of industry experience
- Dave Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider
Accepted payment methods
Customer experiences
Our clients often praise us for our attentive service and reliable insurance solutions, reflected in our high ratings. Hear what others have to say and see why we're a trusted name in Wisconsin. We value feedback and encourage you to share your experience with Agency Insurance, helping others make informed decisions about their coverage needs.
Janine is great to work with! She helped us get a great rate with excellent coverage. We appreciate the time she took to explain our options and how insurance really works. It was much better than trying to figure out everything online or over the phone with a faceless company.
Janine has been great! Very thorough and well versed with the transition of insurances. Highly recommend!
I’m a relatively newer client with Janine (1 year) and it’s just been great to work with her. I’ve done everything from renters, to auto, to home owners just within this past year, and each time she’s been responsive to my needs and is able to move quick to make things happen when there’s a deadline. Would recommend!
I've been with Janine and Erie for about 7 years now and it was the best switch I ever made. Janine is always helpful and available when we need her. If you need a new insurance company and agent look no further!
FAQs about Agency Insurance
What types of insurance do you offer?
Agency Insurance offers home, auto, life, and commercial insurance coverage.
Where is Agency Insurance located?
We are located at 114 S Main St, Lake Mills, WI 53551.
How can I contact Agency Insurance?
You can visit our office, or reach us via our website or phone for inquiries.
Is Agency Insurance a Dave Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider?
Yes, Agency Insurance is a Dave Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider in Southern Wisconsin.
Do you represent a specific insurance provider?
Yes, we are proud representatives of ERIE Insurance.



